An intimate Italian experience in the heart of historic downtown Mystic, CT. A local favorite, featuring an extensive menu and wonderful ambiance - a memorable experience by all standards.
The Restaurant
Anthony J's offers a delicious menu that always includes fresh seafood, Canadian lobster, Angus beef, Canadian veal, imported pasta, made-to-order salads, unique appetizers and our famous daily blackboard specials. Some of our favorites include Soupy & Roast Garlic Pizza, Housemade Lasagna and Sea Scallops in a Vodka Cream Sauce. Don’t forget to leave room for your favorite Italian desserts.
View Our Full Menu
The Bar
Your Anthony J's experience begins in our warm and friendly bar, where you may choose from our renowned wine cellar, enjoy a specialty martini or cocktail, or find your favorite beer from our international selection. Can't wait for dinner or want to start with dessert? Appetizers are designed to share and our desserts are all made on the premises.
“Our first dinner out since COVID and this hidden gem in Mystic was worth the wait. We had a great meal outside on their deck. The service was outstanding and the food was delicious. We will definitely return.”
— JOHN H.
“We ate outside and it was very delightful! They had heaters and tables were spaced properly. The food was very good and so were the cocktails and the service was very good. Definitely recommend!”
— MICHELLE J.
“Located about 100 feet from the water on Holmes Street, AJs offers an intimate, but family friendly atmosphere with delicious Italian Food, including homemade pasta. The great food and jazz-inspired atmosphere is an excellent choice for those looking to escape the hectic, busy downtown touristy area.”
— CHRISTOPHER D.
Location
6 Holmes Street
Mystic, CT 06355
Hours
Please note: We are closed Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve and Christmas Day. New Year’s Eve we are open regular hours 12-9pm, and New Year’s day we open at 4pm.
Monday - Thursday, 4pm to 9pm
Friday - Sunday, 12pm to 9pm
Happy Hour: Monday - Friday, 4pm-6pm
Takeout available!
Contact
(860) 536-0448